Stillwater by Lennar
Brand new, and the only 55+ community in the area with a golf course.
The short answer: Stillwater by Lennar is a 55+ age-restricted community in St. Johns, FL, St. Johns County, built by Lennar. Selling new construction. Nearest beach: Mickler Beach – 16 mi (28 min).
- County
- St. Johns County
- Builder
- Lennar
- Status
- Selling new construction
- Nearest beach
- Mickler Beach – 16 mi (28 min)
Reviewed September 2026 by Brian Sacks, SRES®. Confirm current inventory, HOA dues and any CDD with the builder or HOA before you buy.
Why buyers look at Stillwater by Lennar
- You pick the plan and the finishesLennar is still building here, so you choose the floor plan, the lot and the design-center selections instead of inheriting someone else's.
- Everything is under warrantyNew systems, a new roof and a builder warranty mean fewer surprise repair bills in the first years.
What to watch out for
- The sales center works for the builderThe onsite consultant represents the builder. Register with your own agent on your very first visit, because most builders will not let you add one afterward.
- Base price is not the real priceLot premiums and design-center upgrades add up fast. Compare the finished price against resales in nearby 55+ communities before you commit.
- Age qualification rulesFederal HOPA rules require 80% of occupied homes to have at least one resident 55 or older, and each community sets its own rules for the rest. If a younger spouse or family member may live with you, confirm the policy in writing.
Common questions about Stillwater by Lennar
Is Stillwater by Lennar still building new homes?
Yes. Stillwater by Lennar is selling new construction from Lennar. Ask about current phases, quick move-in homes and incentives, and bring your own agent on your first visit.
How far is Stillwater by Lennar from the beach?
Nearest beach: Mickler Beach – 16 mi (28 min).
Does Stillwater by Lennar have a CDD fee?
Ask before you buy. Many Northeast Florida communities carry a Community Development District assessment on top of HOA dues. It appears on your property tax bill, not your HOA statement, so always compare the all-in monthly cost.
What is the age requirement at Stillwater by Lennar?
Stillwater by Lennar is a 55+ age-restricted community operating under the federal Housing for Older Persons Act, which requires at least 80% of occupied homes to have a resident aged 55 or older. Confirm the community's specific rules for younger occupants in writing.
How it stacks up against the others
There are twenty 55+ communities in Northeast Florida. Comparing two or three properly — on all-in monthly cost, resale history and how the community is aging — is worth more than touring six.
Thinking about Stillwater by Lennar?
Call and I will tell you straight whether it fits what you are actually after — including when the answer is no.